v rainwater wrote:As far as our "foriegn policy' goes, the following link (decorated Marine Gen. Smedley Butler circa 1935) is informative. I'm not buying that "they hate us because of our liberty or freedom" crap. Smedley says it very well.
I am sure that was sarcasm on Fish’s part. The foreign policy of America is complicated twisted and in some regards grotesque. I will read the link you supplied next week once I am done studying for a test, but American foreign policy is far to complicated to justly cover here. Foreign policy in regards to the Middle East is so conflicted that you could probably spend a good portion of your life studying it. It is a story of constant undermining, proliferation of people and resources, ideologies that have no bearing in a society and hundreds of other actions that have brought us to where we are right now. There are people that hate us, there is far more to it than us not conforming to their ideological guidelines, and in large our Cold War dealings were largely responsible for arming a number of these non-state vigilantes. I like how Samir Kassir, a Lebanese intellectual assassinated by agents of the Syrian military, analyzes the situation in the Middle East in a book I read (called “Being Arab”);
“For whether if is or is no longer a foreign agent, Islamism still reinforces the Other. In justifying, or enacting, the clash of civilizations, it gives supporters of the crusade their rationale and enables the West to use all the means afforded it by its technological capabilities to maintain its supremacy over the Arabs, and thereby to perpetuate Arab powerlessness.”
v rainwater wrote:Matt, as far as the vast conspiracy goes, your probably right. However, consider the warnings of the secret few elite string pullers which several have warned of (Gen. Cornwallis, George Washington, Benjamin Franklin,JFK, Regan, Bill Moyers). And a much larger problem than too much not neccessarily true info in the hands of the "uneducated" is the constant barrage of disinfo and propaganda that the sheeple get through the mainstream. It seems to me we've become too "specialized" as individuals and not well rounded, so to speak. Some of the most close minded individuals I know are also the most educated.
This is all more sensible than what you posted originally, I know this conversation has diverged, and maybe you were trolling for responses with your OP. None of this changes my original view though.
I agree that there is a "barrage" of disinformation, a large portion of what we hear is what the mainstream media wants us to hear and all that good stuff, but I think the propaganda rings just as true on the opposite side of mainstream thinking. "Free thinkers", anarchist, non-conformists, patriots and/or whatever these people like to consider themselves are just as susceptible to be fed manipulative highly-hypothetical lies as well. The people that think for them selves are those that can read between the lines without any impartiality taking that information in to account and applying it rationally. Two current examples of this;
a. This story you originally posted. Is there really some atrocious violation of constitutional rights going on here? No. Are there people that want you to believe otherwise? Yes.
b. The suicide avenger down in Austin. Are there people trying to promote his ideas as valid or even worse an expanding consensus in the population? Yes. Do they even realize how contradictory his whole diatribe is? No.
As for becoming too specialized I really don’t have an opinion on this. I do know academically speaking your field of study becomes increasingly specialized the further you pursue higher levels of education. If anything an increasingly globalized world and greater ease of access to information would point toward a wider wealth of knowledge for everyone. So maybe I don’t agree with that statement.
Either way everyone is entitled to think what they want, how they want, and the fact alone that we can publicly agree or disagree with the government in a public forum is what is great about America.
We have diverged past the point of return, and I have side-tracked myself from studying way too far.
-Matt