Naked inline four vs sport touring twins?

[JeffT]

It really depends on you. I like the versys. If I could only have one bike a KLR650 would be it.

[JeffT]

Budget? Are you going to do anything with the bike other than ride 25 miles each way to work? Is your commute on interstate where trafffic moves 70-75mph? Riding experience?

It's nice to have some sort of hard luggage on a commuter. Lets you lock things up when off the bike and keeps things dry hopefully.

[BMuu]

Go with what fits you and you enjoy riding. (fits size and personality) Riding is all about the enjoyment you get out of it.

I have an 03 R1 and Love it! (not a good first bike) Though It's pure pleasure riding but back before I worked from home I enjoyed commuting on it.

Just FYI most the V twins I have seen dont get as good MPG as the I4 so check that if you're looking to save money on gas.

[JeffT]

I was about to talk about the 250 dual purpose bikes if the commute didn't have more than a mile of interstate. They get 70mpg, have cheap tires, and can be left downstream for a shuttle.

[riggin]

I ride a Suzuki V Strom and love it! The average mpg is 50-60 and it's a v-twin. If you are commuting or doing a little sport touring, the versys would be the one because of the seating position, but that's only my opinion. They are both good bikes.

Cheers